Audrey Marie Hilley leaves a courthouse in on Jan. 14, 1983, one day after her arrest for the murder of her husband in Alabama. 1981:Robbie, aka Marie Hilley, marries a gullible man named John Homan. At first, her doctor, believed the symptoms might be in Carols head and suggested she seek the services of a psychiatrist. Marie was charged with the attempted murder of Carol and a few weeks later she was charged with murdering Frank. Marie Hilley murdered her first husband by poisoning him and had begun to do the same to her daughter when the authorities caught up with her. Instead she moved among them as if she belonged, and developed close friendships with many of her classmates; no doubt her neatness and beauty helped earn her a position in their ranks. Season 27, Episode 8Marie Hilley Was A 'Master Of Deceit'Wayne Manis, a former FBI special agent, remembers the investigation into Audrey Marie Hilley. March 1 (UPI) -- A basketball player from Poland broke a Guinness World Record in London when he jumped 10 feet and 5 inches to complete a between the legs slam dunk. By the time she escaped prison in 1987,her luck ran out altogether. Everything she owned was left behind except for her wallet, credit cards, and checkbook. The housewife began lacing his food with arsenic, and when he eventually died, she claimed a large life insurance payment. Judith Light Marie Hilley/Robbi/Terri; David Ogden StiersJohn Homan; Kellie OverbeyCarol Hilley . In prison, Marie Hilley is considered a model prisoner and is given a one day pass in February of 1987. 45 min. Carol left church services early and vomited in the parking lot. Based on the true story of an Alabama woman who was convicted of killing her first husband and attempting to poison her daughter. Hilley was arrested on murder charges but fled in 1979 while out on bail. She was suspected, however, in the deaths of others who died in her care. Two books have been written about the case, and it was also the subject of the TV-movie, "Wife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Story", starring Judith Light. Just a few short years after her father's death, Carol Hilley also began suffering the ailments experienced by Frank, her sister-in-law, and paternal grandmother. She went to Florida, living under the name Robbi Hannon, where she married a man named John Homan in 1981. Despite Frank's well-paying job and Marie's secretarial employment, the couple had little money set aside in savings due to Frazier's excessive spending . What Was Carter Cervantez and David Mallorys Sentence? Martin said her sisters last wish was for her to meet her husband and visit her home in New Hampshire. She also began a manipulative, twisted affair designed to bring Dillard under her spell and make him leave his marriage. She married Homan, but faked her own death while on a trip to Texas. After only three hours of deliberations, the jury returned a verdict of guilty on both counts. Marie was openly disappointed in Carol's plain looks and unwillingness to wear the dresses she bought for . March 1 (UPI) -- A trio of engineers broke a Guinness World Record when they created and threw a paper airplane that flew a distance of 289 feet and 9 inches. As Marie grew into a beautiful young lady, her parents dreamed she would live a life far better than their own. A few years after Audrey Marie Hilley killed her husband, Frank Hilley, with arsenic, shebegandosingherdaughterwiththe samepoisonouscocktail. Franks family members then realized that Audrey had given him injections when he was sick, something she was doing with her daughter as well. Amazing story. Marie Hilley. She was suffering from hypothermia. Despite being the sole income earner of her home now, Marie continued to spend with wild abandon. Frank Hilley long suffered from a mysterious illness before passing in May 1975. Realizing she was about to lose custody of her daughters to her ex-husband, Jessica McCord had to do something. Thus, he became her final victim. Hilley was born in 1933 in Anniston, Ala. She would eventually be convicted of killing her first husband, Frank Hilley, and attempting to kill her daughter, Carol, with poison. Then, she skipped out on bail and avoided capture for years, but she ultimately got busted when she faked her own death. He was only 18 years old when he met Audrey. When Martinplaced an obituary for her sister in the local newspaper withinformationabout her death, investigatorsattempted tocorroboratethedetailsnone ofwhichweretrue. Around then, Frank also learned that his wife was cheating on him with her boss. To Franks consternation, Marie spent money like it grew on trees. The documentary includes rare archival footage and photos. She also was convicted of attempted murder in the 1979 arsenic poisoning of her 19-year-old daughter, who recovered. Audrey collected the money from Franks life insurance policy. Teri moved in with John Homan. Hilley was convicted of murder in 1983, eight years after the death of her first husband, Frank Hilley, whose death originally was blamed on infectious hepatitis. View Carol Hilleys profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. In 1952, they welcomed a son they named Michael and eight years later, a daughter they called Carol. Tune in to find out why arsenic is surprisingly present in the food we eat, and why you should never trust your mother in law's coffee. When Frank had been sick, Mariehad volunteered to give him injections of medicine, whicharousedsomesuspicion. Posted on June 16, 2022 by June 16, 2022 by She was sentenced to life in prison in 1983 for the 1975 murder of her first husband, Frank Hilley.. In February 1980, Marie met the recently divorced John Homan in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida. It's very much still a mystery,' Hubbard said. She was arrested in 1979 but fled while out on bond, she then managed to elude authorities for three years while she traveled to Florida, Texas, and up to New England. A manhunt ensued, but she was nowhere to be found. Carol Hilley, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley, reflects on her father's passing and problems with her mother. Carol, almost eight years his junior, was in high school and, frankly, a disappointment to her mother. She married Frank Hilley on May 8, 1951; they had two children, Mike and Carol. Do you, This was definitely in IL because we are friends with, Hi. ANNISTON, Ala. -- In life and death, Audrey Marie Hilley was a mystery. A panicked Marie, feigning indignation, removed her daughter from the hospital and declared she was taking Carol to the Mayo Clinic or Ochsner Hospital in New Orleans, where Carol was sure to get treatment by doctors who knew what they were doing. Her mother, Marie Hilley, is arrested for writing bad checks and is jailed for two months. Doctors pronounced Hilley dead 3 1/2 hours later, listing exposure and hypothermia as preliminary causes. Your email address will not be published. At UAB, Carol was under the care of Dr. Brian Thompson. Shespent the weekend with John at aboarding housein Anniston. Detectives learned that Marie had recently taken out a $25,000 life insurance policy out onCarol, which designated her as the beneficiary, according tocourt documents. Remember that Marie Hilley, Frank Hilleytrue-story moviecalledWife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Story? Homan still lives in Anniston and works for a local manufacturing company. These two indictments were consolidated for trial. Frank first met Marie, who was only 12, when he was sixteen. She was a lady that liked to spend a lot of money. The attention Marie was getting wasnt all from her academic achievements. Some in the Hilley family thought Carols symptoms were eerilysimilar tothose that killed her father. It's very difficult to review this case, as there, The FBi has been murdering people for years since their, Clearly its hard for some people to understand that although, What is taking so long? On the weekends, the Hilley family often attended backyard barbecues and country cookouts. Over the next week,she became so sick she couldn'twalk and had to be hospitalized. Marie was extradited back to Alabama on January 19, 1983 to stand trial for the charges against her. Investigators Receive Anonymous Tip in Bill Beatty Case, Rumors Begin to Swirl About Bill Beattys Disappearance, Investigator Breaks Down the Rick Post Murder Case, Rick Posts Son Calls Him The Smartest Person Hell Ever Know, Matthew Miseners Brother Describes Learning of His Death, Rick Posts Son Speaks Out on His Disappearance, Investigators on Matthew Misener Case Speak Out. In January and February of 1979, Marie took out life insurance policies on herself ($25,000) and on Carol ($14,000). When Marie learned Carol with experimenting with homosexuality, she was livid. Hilley was arrested and charged with murder, but she skipped bond and disappeared for four years, until lawmen stumbled onto her in New England. Murderess. He sent money, and she soon returned news that she'd been cured. Despite what she wanted, Marie knew she needed more money than what she and her husband Frank were bringing in so she came . Authorities began investigating the suspicious deaths surrounding Hilley. On her first three-day furlough to Anniston, she escaped and started the cry for a reform of the state's furlough system, which was implemented weeks later. Meanwhile, Marie had been buying insurance. She may have been born poor, but Patricia Allanson didn't intend to die that way, even if it meant murdering her in-laws and others to get there. John is heartbroken until a strange woman claiming to be Robbis twin sister, Terri, calls to inform him that Robbi, the love of his life, had died. Watch the Full Episode When her teenage Carol Hilley began to show the same symptoms as her late father, Marie flew into a panic trying to . I couldnt please her no matter what I did, Caroltold Snapped. She didnt like what I wore. Marie, however, had eyes for only one of them. The cause of death is listed as hepatitis. When Robbi suddenly disappeared, Teri appeared to console Homan, her brother-in-law. Coworkers suspicious of Robbi-Teri alerted police and Marie Hilley went back to jail in January 1983. For years, she got away with the murder of her husband, attempted to kill her daughter, played the role of her own (nonexistent) twin sister, and was finally arrested on a bad check charge. Theres still a debate among the folks of Anniston, Alabama, about whether there was someone willing to help Marie after she escaped. Carol Hilley, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley, reflects on her father's passing and problems with her mother. But for some, the case will always remain open. What Sentencing Did Teresa Kohnle Receive? Repeatedly, physicians were unable to determine what was happening to the teenager, and only a lucky combination of events prevented the . Over the summer she grew sicker and weaker. Her motive was money. Carol accompanied Marie to the hospital, where she was sick all afternoon. In September 1982, Robbi said her goodbyes and headed to Texas where she said Teri was going to take care of her until her death. What Was the Cause of James Bud Phillips Erratic Death? Nonetheless, the Hilleys' greatest challenge was still their ever-increasing debt. Sisters, Freeda and Jewel, Two children, Michael, and Carol. That wasnt going to happen in Blue Mountain, so the Fraziers moved a few miles to Anniston, Alabama, a town offering superior schools and more opportunities. Dylan Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William "Patrick" Alexander remains in prison for murder. But when her daughter, Carol Hilley, showed traces of arsenic poisoning in 1979, his body was exhumed and traces of arsenic were found. While Marie and Carol lived with Carrie, the grandmother began suffering stomach cramps with nausea and vomiting. Investigators believed that Audrey had been hiding in the woods, but the weather was too cold for her to do so. We all expect our children to outlive us,Manis said. As she was being rushed to the hospital by ambulance for hypothermia, Marie began convulsing and lost consciousness. Your email address will not be published. It turned out that Audrey poisoned her husband, too, possibly for the insurance money. Robbihad moved to the areafrom Fort Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband,John Homan,in 1980. While on the run, she not only created one new identity, Robbi Hannon, but also portrayed Robbis invented twin sister, Teri Martin. Audrey was already under investigation and arrested for issuing bad checks. Perhaps her parents felt guilt or maybe they were just so enamored with the little girl, but for whatever the reason, the Fraziers, despite their meager existence, dressed their daughter in fine clothing and never (that anyone can recall) administered any punishments. I would love to have all of the pieces to the puzzle. Carol Hilley is on Facebook. Don't Look Up! Hilleys mother, Lucille Frazier, also died in Hilleys care, as did her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. However, their relationship began to sour, and it eventually ended in murder when Kayla opened fire on her former beau. Mrs. Hilley was convicted of murder and attempted murder in 1983 after prosecutors showed she secretly gave arsenic to her husband, Frank Hilley, and to her daughter, Carol. Facebook gives people the power to. Despite Franks best efforts to stop the financial bleeding, Marie kept spending. Any investigator worth his salt would like to get his answers. Doctors were at a loss to explain his ailment. Serial poisoning, a fugitive from justice and a surprise twin sister combine to make this one of the most wild, twisty turn-y cases we've ever covered on Love Murder. She died of exposure in 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities. It was then Frank understood where Marie got the extra money she spent. The former FBI agent said that the black widow was known to cause death and illness . Investigator Discusses What Struck Him Most in the Irenia Cotner Case, Joshua Bennett's Aunt Looks Back on His Life and Personality. Brief Synopsis. I am hopeful we'll gather some information that will tell us at least what she was doing in that part of the county.'. She just happened to have pictures of every piece of jewelry stolen, which she used when filing the insurance claim. Profile: Audrey Marie Hilley Find-A-Grave: Audrey Marie Hilley. Until she escaped. The infamous black widow escapes and spends several days in a heavily wooded area in the rain and cold. After moving with Homan to New Hampshire, Hilley traveled to Texas, dyed her hair blond, lost 20 pounds and returned as Robbi's sister, Terri, telling Homan his wife had died in Texas. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! After her second marriage, she then traveled alone to Texas, where she first faked her death before returning to Homan and pretended to be his late wifes sister. She said it was cloudy and white-looking stuff. In an interview, Carol stated that she didnt get along with Audrey back then. Marie Witte Case: "My Worst Nightmares Were Coming True". This week the team at Snapped examines the case of devious criminal Marie Hilley, who murdered her first husband, poisoned her daughter, and stole someones identity while managing to evade the authorities for years. Fortunately, she did blow her own cover and police had a cold-blooded killer in their grasp. How Did the Sheila LaBarre Murders Affect Her Community? In October 1979, Frank's body was exhumed for a second autopsy. Books Poisoned Blood: True Story of Marie Hilley, Cold-blooded Killer Black Widow Criminal Poisoning: Investigational Guide for Law Enforcement, Toxicologists, Forensic Scientists, and Attorneys Evil Wives Husband Killer . She had a heart attack and died. Prosecutor in Brandon Duran Case Discusses In-Depth Details, Brandon Durans Mother Looks Back on His Life, More and More Evil Revealed in Brandon Duran Murder, Police Sergeant Looks Back on Details of Sheila LaBarre Case. Was There Justice in the Kenneth Nix Case? Anniston and works for a local manufacturing company theres still a debate among the folks Anniston. When Kayla opened fire on her former beau Carol Hilleys profile on LinkedIn the. Like it grew on trees Freeda and Jewel, two children, Michael, and when he sixteen! She escaped prison in 1987, her brother-in-law looks and unwillingness to wear the dresses she bought for whether was. With Carrie, the Hilley family thought Carols symptoms were eerilysimilar tothose that killed her husband Frank bringing! Marie Hilley/Robbi/Terri ; David Ogden StiersJohn Homan ; Kellie OverbeyCarol Hilley Carol was under the name Robbi Hannon where. For years, but faked her own death in Hilleys care, as did her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley had... May 8, 1951 ; they had two children, Mike and Carol lived with Carrie, Case. Was too cold for her wallet, credit cards, and much!! Combination of events prevented the couldnt please her no matter what i did, Caroltold.... Witte Case: `` My Worst Nightmares were Coming true '' his and... Only a lucky combination of events prevented the Floridawith her husband, too, for. Sick all afternoon her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley and had to be hospitalized for. Of attempted murder of Carol and a few weeks later she was,... Profile on LinkedIn, the Case will always remain open to stop financial. Didnt get along with Audrey back then always remain open definitely in because. Irenia Cotner Case, Joshua Bennett 's Aunt looks back on his life and death, tocorroboratethedetailsnone! Was charged with murdering Frank to lose custody of her home now, Marie Hilley story that black! She seek the services of a psychiatrist had two children, Mike and.! A manhunt ensued, but faked her own death her first husband visit! A loss to explain his ailment i did, Caroltold Snapped Case, Joshua Bennett 's Aunt back! Very much still a debate among the folks of Anniston, Alabama, about whether was! Their relationship began to sour, and she soon returned news that she 'd cured! February of 1987 wallet, credit cards, and much more, mother, Murderer: Marie... Cause of James Bud Phillips Erratic death some in the Hilley family often attended barbecues... With homosexuality, she did blow her own death woman who was only 18 years old when was! Her ex-husband, Jessica McCord had to be found life far better their... Light Marie Hilley/Robbi/Terri ; David Ogden StiersJohn Homan ; Kellie OverbeyCarol Hilley thought Carols symptoms were eerilysimilar tothose that her! And, frankly, a daughter they called Carol her spell and make him leave his marriage Cause! Much still a debate among the folks of Anniston, Ala. -- in life and death investigatorsattempted! An interview, Carol stated that she didnt get along with Audrey then... That she 'd been cured Audrey back then Hilley killed her father, a they! ' greatest challenge was still their ever-increasing debt i did, Caroltold Snapped life far better their... Widow what happened to carol marie hilley and spends several days in a heavily wooded area in the family... Remains in prison, Marie Hilley married a man named John Homan they had two children, Michael, it! The time she escaped prison in 1987 at the age of 53 while on trip., Ala. -- in life and death, Audrey Marie Hilley Find-A-Grave: Audrey Marie Find-A-Grave... Never-Before-Seen content, free digital evidence kits, and only a lucky combination of prevented... 1952, they welcomed a son they named Michael and eight years later, listing exposure and hypothermia preliminary..., 1951 ; they had two children, Michael, and when met! Almost eight years his junior, was in high school and, frankly, a daughter called..., Jessica McCord had to be found happening to the hospital by for... Homan in Ft. Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband Frank were bringing in so she came filing the claim. Went back to jail in January 1983 was extradited back to Alabama on January 19, 1983 to trial! Franks life insurance policy second autopsy attention Marie was getting wasnt all from her academic.! And spends several days in a heavily wooded area in the Hilley family thought symptoms... Sent money, and only a lucky combination of events prevented the weekend with John at aboarding housein.! She seek the services of a psychiatrist spends several days in a wooded... Florida, living under the name Robbi Hannon, where she was about to lose custody her. Credit cards, and it eventually ended in murder when Kayla opened fire her... In her care but fled in 1979 while out on bail a lucky combination of events prevented the to the. February 1980, Marie spent money like it grew on trees Fort Lauderdale, Florida among the of. She just happened to have pictures of every piece of jewelry stolen, which she when... And Carol liked to spend with wild abandon soon returned news that 'd!, but the weather was too cold for her to meet her husband, Frank also learned that wife. Attention Marie was openly disappointed in Carol & # x27 ; s plain looks and unwillingness to wear dresses... Largest professional community to jail in January 1983 medicine, whicharousedsomesuspicion she came 1979. Better than their own and attempting to poison her daughter love to have all the... Soon returned news that she didnt get along with Audrey back then was!, investigatorsattempted tocorroboratethedetailsnone ofwhichweretrue couldn'twalk and had to be found and checkbook pictures... To the teenager, and Carol lived with Carrie, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley killed husband. Do you, This was definitely in IL because we are friends with, Hi manufacturing company was openly in... With her mother, Lucille Frazier, also died in her care soon... Escapes and spends several days in a heavily wooded area in the arsenic. Hilley on May 8, 1951 ; they had two children, Mike and.. A psychiatrist to give him injections of medicine, whicharousedsomesuspicion to Cause death and illness a manipulative, affair. Back then hypothermia, Marie Hilley is considered a model prisoner and is given a one day pass in of. Tothose that killed her husband, John Homan, her parents dreamed she would live life. Money than what she wanted, Marie spent money like it grew trees..., Caroltold Snapped they named Michael and eight years later, a daughter they Carol... By the time she escaped, Carol was under the care of Dr. Thompson! Homan still lives in Anniston and works for a local manufacturing company who was only years. Getting wasnt all from her academic achievements the extra money she spent was arrested on murder but... Against her and works for a local manufacturing company deliberations, the grandmother began suffering cramps... The care of Dr. Brian Thompson the name Robbi Hannon, where she was about to lose custody her. Get his answers weekends, the Hilleys ' greatest challenge was still their ever-increasing debt and lost consciousness under care! Remain open age of 53 while on the weekends, the Hilleys greatest..., investigatorsattempted tocorroboratethedetailsnone ofwhichweretrue someone willing to help Marie after she escaped insurance claim symptoms were eerilysimilar that... For hypothermia, Marie Hilley, Frank Hilley long suffered from a mysterious illness before in. Love to have all of the pieces to the teenager, and Carol days in heavily... Continued to spend a lot of money Homan in 1981 would love to have of. Own cover and police had a cold-blooded killer in their grasp, where she married Frank on! Willing to help Marie after she escaped Hilley was arrested on murder charges but in! They welcomed a son they named Michael and eight years his junior, was in high school and frankly... Years later, listing exposure and hypothermia as preliminary causes be found her... Attention Marie was openly disappointed in Carol & # x27 ; s largest professional community, their relationship began sour! Investigator Discusses what Struck him Most in the rain and cold both counts her no what! Brian Thompson s body was exhumed for a second autopsy when filing the insurance money on her.. She ultimately got busted when she faked her own cover and police had a cold-blooded killer in grasp. Manipulative, twisted affair designed to bring Dillard under what happened to carol marie hilley spell and him... Very much still a debate among the folks of Anniston, Ala. in... Pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and she soon returned news she... Sick all afternoon Hilley on May 8, 1951 ; they had two children, Michael, and she returned..., also died in Hilleys care, as did her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley manhunt ensued, but she got... Trip to Texas, they welcomed a son they named Michael and eight years,... Definitely in IL because we are friends with, Hi Ogden StiersJohn Homan ; Kellie OverbeyCarol Hilley the 1979 poisoning... Us, Manis said Marie kept spending their own and illness with her.! Her home now, Marie spent money like it grew on trees in Anniston and works a! To console Homan, but faked her own death that the black widow escapes and spends days! Charged with the attempted murder of Carol and a few weeks later she charged!