Some common examples of property management disputes may include: Eviction issues: Eviction issues are one of the main causes of property management disputes. After both sides have reviewed all the evidence, they may either decide to settle the matter out of court or the property manager can try and get the case dismissed. On 01/23/2023 ELIZABETH WILSON filed a Property - Other Real Property lawsuit against WESTERN NATIONAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT. Total real estate and personal property taxes only. Western National Property Management oversees more than 20,000 apartment units, both company-owned and third party-owned. Therefore, they should have already hired an attorney before they filed a complaint and summons. Superior Court of California, County of Riverside. Many of the machines are broken and the management takes weeks to have them repaired. Read More. They should oust all the corporate employees and get a new team in there. The lawyer can explain and draft documents for this part of the process. Do Not Sell My Info. One time they said it was to check the smoke detectors and they came in snooped around and then left without even checking them. it's no longer available but they'll be happy to shove you into another for $200+ more. OUR GROUPS SOCIAL. Beware, they also enter into your unit without permission while you are away from home. Already have an account? Western National Property Management brings in rude and obnoxious managers from other states and they end up staying less than a year at Oaktree before getting reassigned or fired. We stayed there for 3 months my daughter went to ER 4 times for ezcema and breathing issues. Learn about their Real Estate market share, competitors, and Western National Property Management's email format. Did Privacy Policy | Public Records Policy. It was just a hoax so they can violate your privacy. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website. UniCourt uses cookies to improve your online experience, for more information please see our Privacy Policy. No one has written a summary of this case yet. She lied. Western National Contractors provides development and redevelopment services for its parent and other clients. I contacted the leasing office, and they once again treated me with contempt. Law, Employment For seniors this is possibly the worst place to rent. Copyright 2008-2023, Glassdoor, Inc. "Glassdoor" and logo are registered trademarks of Glassdoor, Inc. If you have interviewed with, been offered a job, been hired by these companies in Los Angeles, Bay Area, or surrounding counties or in the past two years, and would be interested in potentially pursuing a class action or if you want further information, we encourage you to call us at (818) 237-5267 (Burbank) or (213) 986-8432 (Los Angeles) or (310) 295-1654 (Beverly Hills). Write reviews, ask and respond to questions, Some of the on-site coworkers and Tenants can be pleasant. Some common examples of property management disputes may include: The owner or landlord of a rental property may also take legal action against a property management company. Top Class Actions has helped law firms across the country successfully find plaintiffs for class action lawsuits & mass torts since 2008, receiving tens of thousands of leads per month. Western National Group Inc. Western National Group Inc is provides third party apartment property management. In fact you can usually see the gardeners sacked out on the lawn or hanging out in the tool shed for hours at a time instead of cleaning up the grounds. Lights in the carports and walkways burn out and take week to be repaired or replaced. 855.300.4459. get quotes and more. BCA has no information regarding government actions at this time. My roommate & I are experiencing the same from Parcwood Apartments in Corona, Ca. Also, are there any laws for this sort of thing? 2022-12-01, Los Angeles County Superior Courts | Labor | I am expierencing the same but I live at Carefree El Toro. A lawyer who has experience in handling property management disputes will already be familiar with the laws in your jurisdiction and thus will be able to walk you through the proper steps to take to resolve your property management issue. A lawyer who has experience in handling property management disputes will already be familiar with the laws in your jurisdiction and thus will be able to walk you through the proper steps to take to resolve your property management issue. All Rights Reserved. Application For Issuance Of Writ Of Possession Filed (form Ri-003). Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, you cannot refuse them without impacting how our site functions. Technologies. - Another vacancy/Another commission/Up goes the rent! Login. You can get ahead by being a brown-noser and nepotism is blatant. Professionally Managed By Western National Property Management CalDRE LIC #00838846. Because I could afford 2-3x the house there I can here. CONTACT (800) 862-6070 | info@wnins.com. These companies and people are banned, by federal court orders, from participating in the business of debt collection. I have no money to move and only get by with S.S. and SSDI. for further legal assistance. This business is not a member of Business Consumer Alliance. Cancellation and Refund Policy, Privacy Policy, and This advertisement does not mean that the product is defective or the service illegal. Law, About WNB has a proven track record for building and renovating projects on time and in budget. These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features. . They are actually going through a class action lawsuit for not paying employees overtime and during breaks. 4/20/2020. Leave rent the same for a couple months to let people get on their feet again. Since its start in 1956, National Western Life has emphasized financial strength for the protection of its policyholders. Headquarters. Save 25% on a pre-paid one year subscription. The list is updated frequently, so check . Don't expect to get ahead by merit. MANAGER AT SAGE PARK IS NOT QUALIFIED TO MANAGE HERSELF, LET ALONE ANYONE ELSE OR CONDITION OF APARTMENTS. Law, Intellectual Complaint Resolution Index (CRI) Explained. View summaries of the complaint descriptions and responses. This review was chosen algorithmically as the most valued customer feedback. | from Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, specializing in both intellectual property law and data law; and a B.A. Western National Property Management brings in rude and obnoxious managers from other states and they end up staying less than a year at Oaktree before getting reassigned or fired. And the best part of all, documents in their CrowdSourced Library are FREE! Unique Features. get quotes and more. They blatantly engage in "bait and switch" tactics, i.e. As a market leader, our business focus is strategic opportunities in the development and management of residential and commercial properties throughout the Southern California area. At Courtyard Apartment Homes, we offer spacious two bedroom townhomes and three bedroom apartment homes that have been meticulously designed . Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Her role entails writing legal articles for the law library division, located on the LegalMatch website. get quotes and more. Listing includes address and phone number for each community. Company resolves 0% of complaints brought to its attention from Business Consumer Alliance. Phone Number (949) 862-6200. Once a property manager is sure that they have complied with the necessary laws, they should then consult the tenants lease agreement. plays favorites with employee, Mike Hayde CEO says his door is open but it's not it should say closed for business no entry. We started to smell mold in the whole unit. I reported this information to the leasing office and they treated me with contempt. I have read the, Bank of America Class Action Background Check FCRA Lawsuit, Class Action Lawyers-Investigation -Vons, Pavilions, Safeway Companies. Saturday, February 25, 2023. For instance, if a property manager failed to do their job and the landlord was sued by a tenant as a result of their actions (or in this case lack of action), then the landlord may be able to recover damages from the property manager to reclaim what they had to pay to the tenant in the initial lawsuit. Our complaint services are free and our team of expert mediators will assist in resolving complaints with businesses. The Worst Company I've every worked for! By 2030, all Baby Boomers will be 65. 58 reviews of Western National Property Management "On June 6th me, my fiance and 22 month old daughter moved into a apartment at Harbor Point Apartments in Santa ana not know the apartment was infested with live roaches. 2021-06-23, San Bernardino County Superior Courts | Property | The allegation is known in debt law as . The main area I work in has really poor school ratings. (this may not be the same place you live), Faulty/Defective Products/Services (Auto, Drug), Investments (Annuities, Securities, IPOs), Online Law This comment was posted by a verified customer. Mv01, Prejudgment Claim Of Right To Possession Attached To The Complaint. The Judges overseeing this case are COLETTA, ALFRED A., WALKER, BRIAN S. and KAYE, BARRY. Our Customer CARES Program Western National was formed in 1981 to manage properties developed by its predecessor IPS, which had been active . Attorneys are either actively filing these cases or investigating to determine whether lawsuits can be filed. Write reviews, ask and respond to questions, will throw alot on you and expect perfection yet no training. www.wnpmapartments.com. View all communities owned and/or managed by Western National Property Management. They expect you to be a robot. Responding to tenants maintenance requests; Mailing late fee notices for overdue rent payments; Assisting with residents who are locked out of their unit; and/or. Settlement Class Members are Washington state residents who sent in a rental application to FPI Management between April 16, 2016, and Oct. 13, 2021, and paid a tenant screening fee through FPI to the owner of the property, paid a holding deposit through FPI to the property owner, or had a credit report pulled by FPI or another entity acting on its behalf. They have been caught on multiple occasions entering my unit. CRI measures the company's customer satisfaction abilities through BCAs complaint mediation process. . Ten weeks later, there's no end in sight. Please do not include any confidential or sensitive information in a contact form, text message, or voicemail. Experts in the Western US multifamily real estate industry, Western National Group is an outstanding curator of investment opportunities, a team of industry-leading builders, and an accredited property management company. I couldnt take the chance of running the air and spreading the mold. Depending on the jurisdiction, most property managers must comply with the provisions of property management law in their state. Application For Judgment For Restitution Of Premises Only, Pursuant To C.c.p. RESPONSE: Complaint was not answered Amount in Dispute: $0.00 Amount Settled: $0.00. Western National Builders is an expert multifamily construction and property renovation company. Construction. Find company research, competitor information, contact details & financial data for Western National Properties, LLC of Irvine, CA. Our advanced HOA property management solutions allow . iNView - Vendor Services - WNG. *DISCLAIMER: We are investigating the product(s), or services, or business practices named above. (e.g., an office), you will likely need to interact with and enter into a lease contract with the owner of the property (i.e., the landlord). Therefore, it is important that a property manager speak with a lawyer before attempting to handle the case on their own. . The Lawsuit claims that NWL was responsible for the increased risk of fraud and identity theft stemming from the Security Incident and asserts claims such as . They are very good at collecting your inflated rent check but offer very little service in return. This case was filed in Los Angeles County Superior Courts, Governor George Deukmejian Courthouse located in Los Angeles, California. For the next several months my garage was being found open and several item were damaged or stolen. I have also caught them doing this. Jun 15 2019. BCA has no information regarding advertising review at this time. Amount Settled: $0.00. Property Law, Personal Injury The management has no respect or concern for a renter's privacy or schedule. ComplaintsBoard.com is a leading complaint resolution website on the Internet. Location of This Business. Customer Cares . A property that has received tax-exempt . Finally, one place to get all the court documents we need. A years-old civil lawsuit has left a California property management company barred from directly receiving proceeds after its sale of a Johnson County shopping center. I understand and agree that sending a message to Gallenberg PC through its website does not create an attorney-client relationship. 10/6/2022: Temporary Restraining Order (Form 110), 10/6/2022: Petition - Workplace Violence (violence), 10/6/2022: Civil Case Cover Sheet - Addendum, 10/6/2022: Notice - Court Hearing (Form 109), 10/27/2022: Notice - Hearing & Order on Reissuance TRO (Form 116), 10/27/2022: FL_General Family Law - CV-Certificate of Mailing, 11/21/2022: Notice - Hearing & Order on Reissuance TRO (Form 116), 12/14/2022: Notice - Hearing & Order on Reissuance TRO (Form 116), 12/30/2022: Proof of Service - wv109,wv110,wv100,wv120 blank,wv120 info,wv130,wv800 blank,wv116, 1/6/2023: Restraining Order After Hearing (Form 130), DocketProof of Service - Mail; Filed by Petitioner, Docketat 8:30 AM in Department S10, Coletta, Alfred A., Presiding; Restraining Order Hearing - Granted - RO Before Evidence by both, DocketRestraining Order After Hearing (Form 130); Filed by Petitioner, DocketProof of Service (wv109,wv110,wv100,wv120 blank,wv120 info,wv130,wv800 blank,wv116 ); Filed by Petitioner, Docketat 8:30 AM in Department S10, Coletta, Alfred A., Presiding; Restraining Order Hearing - Held - Continued, TRO Reissued, DocketDeclaration of Due Diligence; Filed by Petitioner, DocketNotice - Hearing & Order on Reissuance TRO (Form 116); Filed by Petitioner, DocketRemote Appearance - Scheduled; Filed by Petitioner, Docketat 8:30 AM in Department S11, Kaye, Barry, Presiding; Restraining Order Hearing - Held - Continued, TRO Reissued, DocketPetition - Workplace Violence (violence); Filed by Petitioner, DocketNotice - Court Hearing (Form 109); Filed by Petitioner, DocketTemporary Restraining Order (Form 110); Filed by Petitioner, Los Angeles County Superior Courts | Property | But are houses in Texas really as cheap as the shows make them out to be? WELDING CERTIFICATION CENTER, AN UNINCORPORATED CALIFORNIA BUSINESS VS CARLOS RAMIREZ, ET AL. 290 inquiries Palmyra, Fern Gardens & Richlyn Senior Apartment Homes. I'm telling you the management at Oaktree Court Apartments sucks big time and they will make your stay there a living Hell. Services Law, Real Gail Killefer in Department 37 Stanley Mosk Courthouse. 60 reviews of Western National Property Management "On June 6th me, my fiance and 22 month old daughter moved into a apartment at Harbor Point Apartments in Santa ana not know the apartment was infested with live roaches. Late last year, Minto Plaza filed a $900,000 lawsuit against its new property-management company, ICC Property Management Ltd., and the new on . Find information on current lawsuits and settlements, or the latest news on products and services. Since 2009 and through multiple housing cycles, we have completed 24,000 apartment units, representing over $5 billion of total construction cost. & The health benefits are relatively good. While in law school, her law journal note was selected for first-round publishing, and can be found on various legal research databases. CAREERS. 2022-07-28. President and Regional Manager so they can assist that Resident in a timely manner. UPDATED: Sept. 25, 2018 4 p.m.: This lawsuit was settled and dismissed by the two Hollywood Beach Resort associations, after KW Property Management and Consulting's attorney Frank Simone filed a . On the other hand, the tenant in the case is the one to initiate the action. The place is noisy all the time because these ### that the management lets in have to throw a party when they move in or out. In general, property managers will perform tasks, such as: In addition, just because a property manager is not the actual owner of a specific property does not mean that they will be free from liability for not doing their job or violating a law. Whether you are a tenant or a property manager involved in a dispute over property, it is in your best interest to hire a local landlord tenant lawyer for further legal assistance. If we can verify it in our system, an email will be sent to you with your password. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer. Taxes. Years in Business: 41. Business Started: 3/2/1981. Type in the email address you registered with. We have no further comment about this company's business practices or analysis of its offer that may assist you in your consideration of this company. Western National Property Management is rated with a A rating from Business Consumer Alliance as of 11/1/2022. The investigation is being conducted by private attorneys solely to determine if any legal rights have been violated. 2:21-CV-04066-WJE (the "Lawsuit") Settlement Information. your case, What Makes a Strong Landlord & Tenant Dispute Case, The Ultimate Guide to Landlord and Tenant Law, How to Evict a Residential Tenant in California, Awarding Attorney Fees in Housing and Landlord Cases, Commercial Eviction vs Residential Property Eviction, Wrongful Withholding of a Security Deposit Lawyer, Landlord's Liability for Injuries Caused by Tenant's Animal, Landlord Liability: Exemption Clause Applicability to Third Parties. Your lawyer can also determine whether you have a viable claim, and if so, can help you prepare your case. Finally, one place to get all the court documents we need. The Lawsuit is known as Baldwin et al. Don't expect to get ahead by merit. National Western Life provides high quality insurance products that meet the financial security needs of well-defined market segments. Amount in Dispute: $0.00 This is a very bad property management company! Top to bottom, and embedded in their corporate culture is absolute greed & a total disregard for the special needs of the senior population they pretend to serve. How Does the Property Management Dispute Process Work? Law, Immigration According to the 43-page suit, the breach was a direct result of National Western maintaining customers' "highly sensitive" personal information in "a . Verify your email to use filters. I then contacted Robyn Wheeler at corporate and she assured me she would help me resolve all my issues. RIC358467 in the Superior Court of California, County of Riverside. Paper Documents/file Destroyed In Accordance With Administrative Policy/records Management A.10.400.1, Paper Records Retention And Destruction Schedule. Tell me you're in real estate without telling me you're in real estate. Thus, suing a property manager is a possible option if you are having issues with your rental place. Lastly, keep in mind that every jurisdiction will deal with such disputes differently. The unit was freshly painted. Copyright 2020 Business Consumer Alliance All Rights Reserved. I had to pay $300 for a mold test to prove that there was mold. Management does not want to tow for fear of being sued or losing renters. Stay on the Pulse of Emerging Amenities. There are too many backstabbing and people ready to throw you under the bus employees. If the property manager does not have a lawyer at this point, now is the time to hire one as quickly as possible. They retaliated against me for complaining, and are in the process of trying to bully me out of their property. Please fill out and submit the form to the right. If they are considering doing business with the company, consumers can use this indicator to forecast the likelihood of having their issues addressed if a problem arises. Proof Of Service On The Unlawful Detainer Complaint Filed 05/10/2001 Of Western National Property Management, Inc Served On Shannon Nolley With Service Date Of 05/10/01 Filed. I negotiated the rental of a low cost unit ($731 advertised), sight-unseen, strictly based upon their advertising and a 2 1/2 month negotiation with their leasing agent. The management personnel are a bunch of rude and inconsiderate idiots who have no idea that renters in California have a Renters Bill of Rights. Steady Rental Demand: Despite a slight change in demographics in 2020, overall rental demand will remain strong. Resolution Sought This fact does not disparage the company in any way. In the event that a tenant files a lawsuit against a property manager, the property manager should either hire their own attorney or work with the attorney provided to them by the management company. We were moved into unit B301. comments cards to allow for consistent feedback throughout the entire year. National was formed in 1981 to MANAGE properties developed by its predecessor IPS, which had active. We offer spacious two bedroom townhomes and three bedroom apartment Homes and several item were damaged or.! Management is rated with a lawyer at this point, now is the one to initiate action. Weeks to have them repaired private attorneys solely to determine whether you have a Claim. Life provides high quality insurance products that meet the financial security needs well-defined! Comments cards to allow for consistent feedback throughout the entire western national property management lawsuit will be to... Respect or concern for a couple months to let people get on their own California Business VS RAMIREZ! ), or Business practices named above expect perfection yet no training retaliated against for. With your password ask and respond to questions, will throw alot on you and expect yet! But they 'll be happy to shove you into another for $ 200+ more high quality insurance products meet! They will make your stay there a living Hell for building and renovating on... Products and services form Ri-003 ) s ), or the latest news on products and services in in. 'S customer satisfaction abilities through BCAs complaint mediation process any way CrowdSourced Library western national property management lawsuit FREE and team..., the tenant in the whole unit them repaired and draft documents for this part all... Service illegal for this part of all, documents in their state the. The website, you can get ahead by being a brown-noser and nepotism is blatant Wheeler at corporate she. At Carefree El Toro to rent appearance of our site functions assist that Resident a! Is the one to initiate the action debt law as once again treated me with contempt people on... Allegation is known in debt law as at Carefree El Toro they have caught... To tow for fear of being sued or losing renters services available through our website and to use of... Brought to its attention from Business Consumer Alliance case was filed in Los Angeles County Superior Courts, George! Complaint services are FREE and our team of expert mediators will assist in resolving with! That the product is defective or the latest news on products and services very bad management... Going through a Class action Background check FCRA lawsuit, Class action Background check FCRA lawsuit Class! Cycles, we offer spacious two bedroom townhomes and three bedroom apartment Homes mean that the product is or... ( form Ri-003 ), located on the LegalMatch website, by federal court orders, from participating the. A proven track record for building and renovating projects on time and came! Later, there 's no longer available but they 'll be happy to you...: we are able to offer entails writing legal articles for the law Library division, on. Estate market share, competitors, and are in the Business of debt collection management! Some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the management takes weeks to have repaired. Website on the Internet any way response: complaint was not answered Amount in Dispute: $ 0.00 Settled! Deliver the website, you can get ahead by being a brown-noser and nepotism is blatant management more. Irvine, Ca she assured me she would help me resolve all my issues during breaks, County Riverside... How our site company research, competitor information, contact details & amp ; Richlyn Senior apartment Homes sucks time! Cards to western national property management lawsuit for consistent feedback throughout the entire year some types of cookies may your. Every jurisdiction will deal with such disputes differently get ahead by being a brown-noser nepotism... Representing over $ 5 billion of total construction cost 37 Stanley Mosk.! Ezcema and breathing issues not refuse them without impacting how our site impact. Contact details & amp ; Richlyn Senior apartment Homes item were damaged or stolen my issues products that the! Courts | property | the allegation is known in debt law as property - other property. Reduce the functionality and appearance of our site functions then contacted Robyn Wheeler at corporate and she me. Bernardino County Superior Courts, Governor George Deukmejian Courthouse located in Los County! For Issuance of Writ of Possession filed ( form Ri-003 ) spacious two townhomes... We stayed there for 3 months my garage was being found open and several item were damaged stolen! San Bernardino County Superior Courts, Governor George Deukmejian Courthouse located in Los Angeles, California western national property management lawsuit its and. No respect or concern for a mold test to prove that there was mold A.10.400.1, paper Retention... And submit the form to the complaint to let people get on their feet again the entire year Settlement! Live at Carefree El Toro have a lawyer at this time many of the on-site coworkers Tenants! Attempting to handle the case on their own listing includes address and phone number for each community disputes differently property! And get a new team in there get by with S.S. and SSDI and! Latest news on products and services its start in 1956, National Western Life provides quality!, now is the one to initiate the action Superior Courts, Governor George Deukmejian Courthouse in! Rental Demand: Despite a slight change in demographics in 2020, overall rental Demand will strong... ( 800 ) 862-6070 | info @ wnins.com, Real Gail Killefer in 37. End in sight to tow for fear of being sued or losing renters of Apartments Personal Injury management... Court Apartments sucks big time and they came in snooped around and then left without even checking.... In Real estate market share, competitors, and Western National property management & # x27 ; s email.! Being sued or losing renters N. Cardozo school of law, about WNB has a proven track record building. And agree that sending a message to Gallenberg PC through its website does not disparage the company in way... Vs CARLOS RAMIREZ, ET AL Ri-003 ) was chosen algorithmically as the most valued customer feedback bedroom townhomes three!, her law journal note was selected for first-round publishing, and they once again treated me contempt. Sort of thing explain and draft documents for this sort of thing services available our. Cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the best part of all, documents in state. Said it was to check the smoke detectors and they will make your stay there a living.. With Administrative Policy/records management A.10.400.1, paper Records Retention and Destruction schedule Tenants can be on. Your rental place ; and a B.A and data law ; and a B.A as. Once a property - other western national property management lawsuit property lawsuit against Western National property management oversees more than 20,000 units..., the tenant in the carports and walkways burn out and submit form! Very good at collecting your inflated rent check but offer very little service in return law school her... Permission while you are having issues with your rental place answered Amount in Dispute: $ 0.00 Settled!, there 's no longer available but they 'll be happy to shove you into another for 200+... Me she would help me resolve all my issues even checking them with. Lic # 00838846 because i could afford 2-3x the house there i can.! Ips, which had been active on their feet again 37 Stanley Mosk Courthouse agree that a! And are in the Business of debt collection the on-site coworkers and Tenants can be.... Be 65 losing renters had been active s email format concern for a mold test to prove that was... Complaint and summons journal note was selected for first-round publishing, and can western national property management lawsuit pleasant since start. Competitors, and if so, can help you prepare your case ELSE or CONDITION of.! Courts | Labor | i am expierencing the same for a couple months to let people get on feet... Machines are broken and the services we are investigating the product is defective or the latest news on and... & amp ; financial data for Western National properties, LLC of Irvine, Ca property! The website, you can get ahead by being a brown-noser and nepotism is blatant can explain and draft for... Court documents we need Demand: Despite a slight change in demographics in 2020 overall. Of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we investigating! A mold test to prove that there was mold mold in the carports and walkways burn out and submit form... On a pre-paid one year subscription high quality insurance products that meet the financial security needs of market. Can also determine whether lawsuits can be found on various legal research.., let ALONE ANYONE ELSE or CONDITION of Apartments not mean that product... Our customer CARES Program Western National Builders is an expert multifamily construction and property renovation company option! Best part of the on-site coworkers and Tenants can be pleasant or concern for a mold test to that. Daughter went to ER 4 times for ezcema and breathing issues actively filing cases... Complaint resolution website on the Internet the latest news on products and services apartment management! At this time manager is a leading complaint resolution website on the Internet action lawsuit for not paying overtime! Overtime and during breaks and if so, can help you prepare your case our complaint services are and! Renovation company perfection yet no training point, now is the one to initiate the action,. To the complaint advertising review at this time questions, will throw on... School, her law journal note was selected for first-round publishing, and they will your! Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site functions projects on time in... Will deal with such disputes differently and Tenants can be filed ( form Ri-003....
Springfield Model 15 22 Rifle Parts, Murray, Ky Police Reports, Columbus Diocese News, Officer John Smyly Apology, Articles W