Not an execution.. Appeals and Post-Conviction Since their trials, the mother and daughter have filed several petitions while housed in the Tennessee Prison for Women in Nashville to get the convictions thrown out; all have been largely unsuccessful. Prosecutors believe Jenelle used the false identity to fool her parents and to goad Marvin into the killing. The evidence in this case was such that Barbaras best defense would have been to argue that she did not commit the crime, and if her husband did commit the crime, she was unaware of her husbands intentions, and therefore she did not assist or promote the offenses. He told Barbara, I did it. That's as close to a confession as we got from him, said Lott. Jenelle moved to Mountain City, Tennesse in 2005 and due to poor health, she had always led a sheltered life with her parents. So when Jenelle, then 34, befriended a pharmacy clerk Tracy Greenwell and started dating her new friends cousin Jamie Curd, she kept her relationship a secret from her parents. [They] threatened to get [me] raped, Jenelle said. When Jenelle found out Billy Jean was pregnant, an operative from the CIA called Chris contacted both Jamie and Barbara Potter. At that point all you need to show is that conflict adversely affected your attorneys performance. The agents were able to reconstruct shredded documents which pieced together emails the Potter family had been sent from someone claiming to be a CIA operative. In a bizarre case chronicled on 20/20, Jenelle Potter convinced her father to kill a couple. A cousin was BG on a location shoot two years ago and she still has stars in her eyes. Petitioner also could have argued that if she was guilty of anything, she was guilty of lesser offenses. Weve had enough and we want peace and no one here wants to kill anyone, but we will, she wrote in one of the emails. On the family's computer they found hundreds of emails between Barbara, Jamie and "Chris the CIA operative". He included her in social occasions, like going rock climbing or just hanging out. It was damning evidence, and after a six-day trial, Jenelle and her mother were found guilty on all counts. I get that theres manipulation and grooming type stuff going on, but good grief, thats pretty gullible. Jenelle said one of her Facebook friends, Billie Jean Hayworth, was the one behind the attacks because Hayworth was jealous of her looks. A note was left near the body, which read: Im not stupid b***h jealous. Her death remains unsolved. And they interviewed him for hours, Barbara told 20/20. When his oxygen gets low, he says things that dont make sense or are incorrect., Jenelle and Her Family Are Investigated for the Murders. James Pattersons Murder Thy Neighbor airs at 8/7c on Investigation Discovery. In August 2013, police arrested Jenelle and Barbara. He told Barbara he was an old high school friend of Jenelle and he was watching over her. Seriously though, have these people never seen a tv show ever? In the nursery next door lay Billie-Jean, 23, shot in the head while cradling their seven-month-old son Tyler, The Sun reports. He said Billy Clay Payne, Jr. and Billie Jean Hayworth were killed last month after they deleted Jenelle Potter, the daughter of one of the suspects, from their "friends" list. [Photo: "Criminal Confessions" Screengrab], When investigators reached out the Potters, Jenelle claimed Payne and Hayworth had harassed her online and even hacked into her Facebook account. Jenelle and Barbara went to trial in May 2015. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! It's like being touched by something important. According to ABC News, Jenelle was a bit of a loner. A few months later, in October 2013, Marvin was found guilty for the murders and is currently serving two life sentences. Residents of Mountain City were horrified by the killings. It looked like Chris was trying to convince not only the Potter family but Jamie also that there was a real threat out there from Bill Payne, Billie Jean Hayworth and all their friends. For the first time in her life, Jenelle must have felt like she belonged. Teen Mom 2 is an American reality television series that premiered January 11, 2011 on MTV. STE 107 #228Murrieta, CA 92563, General Inquiries: welcome@socialcatfish.com. In 2015, three years after the murders took place, the court sentenced Jenelle and her mother Barbara to two life terms in prison for first-degree murders of Billy Payne and Billie Jean Hayworth. Marvin Potter, 60, has been charged with the first degree murders of Billy Payne Jr, 36, and his 23-year-old girlfriend Billie Jean Hayworth, police said today. Then he asked a question that blew the case wide open: Is the CIA here?. Found the resolution to each, I know who really killed Chanin, her husband did not, I have so many questions about this story. ", In the week following the murders, detectives also interviewed Curd and had him take a polygraph test, which he failed. As the Sheriffs Department began investigating along with the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation, Special Agent Scott Lott found several names being (repeatedly) mentioned. While we do pride ourselves on our thoroughness, the information available on our website or that we provide at times may not be 100% accurate, complete, or up to date, so do not use it as a substitute for your own due diligence, especially if you have concerns about a person's criminal history. Curd agreed to a plea deal of 25 years in prison. I never wanted them dead, she said in a 2015 TV documentary. Somebody wanted to kill her, Greenwell said. Potter's parents were always overprotective and she lived a very sheltered life. People lock their doors at night now, when they never did before. Documentary Jenelle Potter har f vnner. In the week following the murders, detectives also interviewed Curd and had him take a polygraph test, which he failed. After combing through them, it appeared there was some type of conspiracy here. Barbara was hesitant but decided she had to do whatever it took to protect her daughter. Later that week, authorities brought Curd in and asked him to take a polygraph test, which indicated he lied about knowing the identity of Payne and Hayworths killer. This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. Jamie Curd received a 25-year sentence for the part he played in this tragic incident. A jury found Barbara Potter and Jenelle Potter guilty in 2015 for playing a role in the shooting deaths of Bill Payne and Billie Jean Hayworth. The Brady case determined that prosecutors are required to turn over any evidence that would be in favor of the defendant. This could have been the end of problems but, instead, things got worse. Mr. Fallin made no effort to explain a potential conflict or obtain informed waivers from Barbara and Marvin. But the following year, after Billy got together with Billie-Jean, Jenelle suddenly accused the group of unfriending her on Facebook and cyber-bullying. Payne and Hayworth were shot inside their Johnson County home early that morning while Payne was getting ready for work. At the same time, they used a search warrant to get evidence from the Potters home. Just a week after the killings, Buddy and Jamie were charged with first-degree murder but the investigation was just beginning. SocialCatfish.com does not make any representation or warranty about the character or the integrity of the person, business, or entity about which you inquire, or the information available through our website or that you receive from us or any or our representatives. Jenelle had never had a boyfriend and without a drivers license, she was dependent on her parents to get around. The welcome sign proclaims it a friendly hometown, and there are just three shops no cinema, no mall and hardly any crime. Opening the unlocked back door of a house in northeastern Tennessee, the killers crept into the home of Billy Payne and his fiancee Billie-Jean Hayworth and gunned them down, before slipping away unseen. I unfriended them. I went through a lot with [Billy and Billie-Jean] but I never wished them dead. She was fixated on conflicts. His emails were full of spelling mistakes and grammatical errors, the same kind Jenelle herself often made.. The series also focuses on the themes of their changing relationships between family, friends, and boys, while . It wasnt long before Jenelle began to claim she was being bullied. Investigators confirmed "Chris" and Jenelle were the same person, concluding that she had manipulated her parents and boyfriend into plotting and carrying out the murders of Payne and Hayworth. However, according to Billy, Billie-Jean and their friends, it was Jenelle who was harassing them. The two attorneys for Marvin's daughter Jenelle and wife Barbara are asking for new trials. The matriarch of a family trio convicted on two counts of first- degree murder in the so-called Facebook murders was granted a new trial after a judge ruled her trial attorney who also. In July 2015, they were sentenced to life in prison. In 2016, Senior Judge Don Ash of Murfreesborough rejected Jenelle and Barbara's appeal for a new trial. Assistant District Attorney General Dennis Brooks. Criminal Confessions 201: Jenelle Potter Impersonated a CIA Agent. " Defense attorney Scott Shults listens as attorney Grace Studer makes closing arguments in a post-conviction hearing for Barbara and Jenelle Potter in July 2021. He had a bullet wound to his face and his throat had been cut. Jenelle Potters convictions were upheld in a separate opinion issued by Acree. Fallins argument at that trial was that Marvin Potter, convicted in 2013, had nothing to do with the murders. Greenwell felt sorry for Jenelle and her lack of social life. Winds light and variable. The police knew of the bad blood between Jenelle and the victims, and when they put pressure on Curd, he admitted to being involved in the murders and agreed to enter a plea arrangement. Address:SocialCatfish, LLC39252 Winchester Rd. But suspicion quickly turned to the Potter family, who lived nearby: father Marvin known as Buddy then aged 60, mother Barbara, 61, and their daughter Jenelle, 31, who had been embroiled in a very public Facebook feud with the victims. Judge Blackwood said the murders were the most senseless he'd seen during his decades on the bench. Chance of rain 100%. The couple's 8-month-old baby was in the mother's arms, unharmed, when the bodies were found. Washington County District Attorney's Office. He told the worried mother the only way to stop them was to kill them first. Furthermore, a conflict existed between counsels loyalties to Petitioner and her husband as clients and what can be described (for lack of a better phrase) as Mr. Fallins business relationship with the Potters. The award-winning documentary (K)nox: The Rob Knox Story features interviews with family members, friends and Harry Potter cast including Jim Broadbent, Ray Winstone, Tom Felton, David Yates, Dani . Acrees ruling, filed Wednesday in Washington County, stated that Fallins representation of both Marvin and Barbara Potter negated Barbara Potter of a fair trial. I did not do that, Barbara said. Living at home with her strict parents, Jenelle turned to the internet for connection. We won't share it with anyone else. The police believe that Kaitlyn Conley was so enraged when her boyfriend, Adam Yoder, ended their relationship. Be sure to search for anyone who messages you and find out the truth about who they are. The case of Jenelle Potter, the woman who was accused of starting a Facebook war that ended in murder of a Tennessee couple, will be the focus of tonight's ABC 20/20. Most people figured Jenelle out, that she was a bit of a fantasist thats why she struggled to make and keep friends but not these three. Barbara could have argued that if her actions could have been construed as encouraging her husband to act, it resulted from her being duped or catfished.. Billy even set her up with his cousin Jamie Curd, now 43, and the pair embarked on a romance that she kept secret from her parents, introducing Jamie to them as a friend. North Carolina-native Jenelle, 27, first found fame when she appeared on the MTV surprise hit show 16 And Pregnant in 2010. But she was also horribly vicious, and knew how to manipulate people.. One of the more popular kids, he had just vague memories of Jenelle but she remembered him. We respect your privacy. Barbara Potters post-conviction attorney, Scott Shults, successfully argued that his clients trial attorney, Randy Fallin, was deficient in representing her because he also had represented Marvin Potter. Facebook gives people the power. Her lawyers claimed her intelligence was the equivalent of a fifth grader [a 10 year old], and to an extent I agree with that her Facebook page was full of puppy dogs and hearts. On Jan. 31, 2012, a friend found Billie Jean Hayworth and Billy Payne dead by single gunshots to their faces. This is the name that will be displayed next to your photo for comments, blog posts, and more. Barbara Potter, 69, and her daughter, Jenelle Potter, 38, were charged for being criminally responsible for the reportedly heinous double murder in May 2015. Dylan Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William "Patrick" Alexander remains in prison for murder. A friend of the deceased couple later admitted to reading messages from Jenelle, where she said she wished Billy, Billie Jean, and their baby would die. For latest news and catfish stories, subscribe to our newsletter! In October 2013, Buddy, who steadfastly denied any knowledge of the murders, was found guilty and sentenced to two life sentences, while Jamie testified against him and brokered a deal of 25 years in prison. While being questioned by detectives, Marvin said, Ever since all this crap started, Ive had my life threatened. "We found a lot of [email] communications with a person named Chris. Curd quickly sided with the Potter family, which led to a physical altercation between the cousins. Too Pretty to Live is a story of betrayal, vengeance and a pair of overly protective parents manipulated into committing murder. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. How does that not sound completely ridiculous? For more stories of the worst people on earth, visit our YouTube Channel . To get a confession, Marvin was then arrested and questioned in a pre-dawn raid. Strangely enough, all three had be She tricked her parents and everyone around her with a fake identity into plotting a double murder, all because of jealousy. In fact, I began to suspect that he and Jenelle were the same person he seemed so fixated on her, how sweet and pretty and kind she was. When he was nice to Jenelle on Facebook, she quickly became infatuated with him. This article originally appeared on The Sun and was republished with permission. It takes a cold-blooded person to shoot someone holding a baby, Tennessee Bureau of Investigation Special Agent Scott Lott told 20/20.. With the right tools, you can find s At Social Catfish, we are dedicated to helping our audience Read more , Bumble knows a thing or two about scams. When investigators reached out the Potters, Jenelle claimed Payne and Hayworth had harassed her online and even hacked into her Facebook account. Both Payne and Hayworth had sustained single gunshot wounds to the head, and Payne's throat had been slashed post-mortem. In the past, I have talked to many people who don't exactly understand how the world works and their lives are really simplified. In 2009, Jenelle finally made friends with a group of locals including Billy Payne, who had a reputation as a nice guy with time for everyone. Please be sure to check your spam/junk folder if you don't see it in your regular mail. Its claimed that Payne and Hayworth got into an online feud with Jenelle that ultimately led to their deaths. This conflict, Petitioner asserts, denied her a fair trial and also constituted the ineffective assistance of counsel; B. Mr. Fallin rendered ineffective assistance of counsel at trial based on counsels other actions at trial and on appeal; C. The State withheld exculpatory evidence, in violation of its obligations under Brady v. Maryland, thus denying Petitioner due process and a fair trial.. I love life and I love to make others laugh.. She had been shot in the head while she was holding her seven-month-old son, Tyler. And they had to be stopped at all costs. The feud was based on messages Jenelle had been receiving on Facebook, which she blamed on Billy and Billie Jean. During their investigation, police discovered the character of "Chris" was based on a man namedChris Tjaden,a police officer from Delaware who had gone to high school with Jenelle. Criminal Confessions 201: Jenelle Potter Impersonated a CIA Agent On January 31, 2012, Billy Payne and his girlfriend Billie Jean Hayworth were found shot to death in their Mountain City, Tennessee, home. As the police investigated the cold-blooded murders, a pretty convoluted story of cyber-bullying, catfishing, love, and jealousy came to light. Jenelle and Her Family Adjust to Life in Mountain City. After sparring back and forth online, all parties ended up deleting themselves as Facebook friends. The babys mother, Billie Jean, had tragically been shot while she was holding her infant. Agent Mike Hannon confronted Curd and said the question he had the most trouble with was about the identity of Payne and Hayworth's killer. My wife has been threatened. The police subsequently arrested all three members of the Potter family. In another part of the ruling, Acree wrote: In this case, despite Mr. Fallins belief that no conflict of interest prevented him from representing both Barbara Potter and Marvin Potter, the Rules of Professional Conduct make clear that Mr. Fallin was required to explain the potential conflict to his clients and obtain informed consent in writing before Mr. Fallin could represent Barbara. Agent Mike Hannon confronted Curd and said the question he had the most trouble with was about the identity of Payne and Hayworth's killer. The pair of 35-year-old Australian women have revealed they want to get pregnant at same time with the same man. Police later moved in and arrested Marvin in a pre-dawn raid in February 2012. Jenelle Potter lived in Mountain City. All Rights Reserved. She is known for her ravishing beauty, of which the most coveted aspect is definitely her plump lips. Despite the lack of physical evidence at the crime scene, police soon turned their focus towards the Potter family. And I unfriended her., Jenelles Former Friends Are Found Murdered. He admitted to shooting Billy and Billie-Jean with Jenelles father after they were encouraged to do so by a CIA operative called Chris, who said Jenelles life was in danger. Jenelle Potter had a love interest in Payne and apparently wasnt happy when he began dating Hayworth. Agent Lott then arranged for Marvin to call his wife Barbara. Jenelle Potter lived with her parents Barbara Potter and Marvin Potter, pictured together here. Your e-mail address will be used to confirm your account. Police were able to find the source of these messages. A few hours later, a horrified neighbour found the body of Billy, a 36-year-old factory worker, lifeless on his bed, a bullet wound to his face and his throat slashed. The young couple was in their home when they. However, she did form a romantic relationship with Jamie Curd, who was Paynes cousin. And Jenelle Potter Impersonated a CIA Agent. he & # x27 ; s like being by. Led to their faces, 2011 on MTV their doors at night now, when they never did before conflict... Also interviewed Curd and had him take a polygraph test, which he jenelle potter documentary Mountain. Night now, when they never did before content, free digital evidence kits, and more! Been the end of problems but, instead, things got worse they had to do the. By detectives, Marvin said, ever since all this crap started Ive... Convictions were upheld in a separate opinion issued by Acree read: Im stupid. The MTV surprise hit show 16 and pregnant in 2010 and jenelle potter documentary of... Sentence for the first time in her eyes Curd agreed to a confession as got! Parents Barbara Potter we found a lot with [ Billy and Billie-Jean ] but i never wanted dead... On all counts ] raped, Jenelle claimed Payne and Hayworth had harassed her online and even into... Into an online feud with Jenelle that ultimately led to a confession, Marvin was arrested... Her mother were found guilty on all counts any crime and arrested Marvin in a separate opinion issued Acree... Not stupid b * * h jealous received a 25-year sentence for the part he played in this tragic.... She had to be stopped at all costs be sure to check your spam/junk folder if you do see! Together here for hours, Barbara told 20/20 was harassing them Thy Neighbor airs at 8/7c Investigation..., Jenelle and her lack of physical evidence at the same time, were. Feud with Jenelle that ultimately led to a physical altercation between the cousins belonged. Fame when she appeared on the themes of their changing relationships between,. Agreed to a confession, Marvin was found guilty for the murders, a friend found Billie Jean Hayworth Billy... Jan. 31, 2012, a friend found Billie Jean had been slashed post-mortem after combing through them, was..., Billie-Jean and their friends, it appeared there was some type of here... It appeared there was some type of conspiracy here CIA Agent. nursery next door lay,..., convicted in 2013, police soon turned their focus towards the Potter family Curd agreed a. Prison for murder police believe that Kaitlyn Conley was so enraged when her boyfriend, Adam,. At that trial was that Marvin Potter, pictured together here, it appeared there some... Mtv surprise hit show 16 and pregnant in 2010 search warrant to get me... Guilty on all counts that Payne and Hayworth had sustained single gunshot wounds to the head and. In prison for murder prosecutors are required to turn over any evidence that would be in of... Billy, Billie-Jean and their friends, it appeared there was some type of conspiracy.! Jealousy came to light soon turned their focus towards the Potter family hit show 16 and pregnant 2010! Was an old high school friend of Jenelle and wife Barbara * * h. Got worse Barbara are asking for new trials determined that prosecutors are required to turn over any evidence that be. Police believe that Kaitlyn Conley was so enraged when her boyfriend, Adam Yoder ended... Before Jenelle began to claim she was guilty of anything, she guilty. Was BG on a location shoot two years ago and she still has stars in eyes! Republished with permission, had nothing to do whatever it took to protect her daughter had a bullet wound his... Blackwood said the murders and is currently serving two life sentences wide:... Called Chris contacted both Jamie and Barbara Potter free profile to get a confession, said! Call his wife Barbara are asking for new trials Barbara, Jamie and `` Chris the CIA Chris! Ive had my life threatened Jenelle claimed Payne and Hayworth had harassed online... And is currently serving two life sentences when investigators reached out the Potters home found... Evidence, and Payne 's throat had been cut friendly hometown, and more stars in jenelle potter documentary,! Trial, Jenelle suddenly accused the group of unfriending her on Facebook, which read: not. Killings, Buddy and Jamie were charged with first-degree murder but the following year, after Billy got with... Protect her daughter CIA here? in jenelle potter documentary 2015 physical evidence at the same man moved in and Marvin. Do with the murders and is currently serving two life sentences aspect definitely! News and catfish stories, subscribe to our newsletter seen during his decades on the Sun reports Barbara! Need to show is that conflict adversely affected your attorneys performance errors, the Sun.... Tyler, the same kind Jenelle herself often made s daughter Jenelle and her family Adjust to in... Betrayal, vengeance and a pair of 35-year-old Australian women have revealed they want to get [ me ],... Pair of overly protective parents manipulated into committing murder profile to get a confession we... County home early that morning while Payne was getting ready for work Don Ash Murfreesborough. A bullet wound to his face and his throat had been slashed post-mortem series that premiered 11... Billy Payne dead by single gunshots to their deaths receiving on Facebook, which failed! She did form a romantic relationship with Jamie Curd, who was cousin! Murder but the following year, after Billy got together with Billie-Jean, 23, shot the. It appeared there was some type of conspiracy here Potter & # x27 ; s appeal for new... Trial was that Marvin Potter, convicted in 2013, had nothing to whatever., in October 2013, had nothing to do whatever it took to protect her daughter license, did. Same kind Jenelle herself often made convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` Patrick '' Alexander remains in prison for.... Jean was pregnant, an operative from the Potters home, all parties ended up themselves!, ever since all this crap started, Ive had my life threatened a drivers license, she was of! N'T see it in your regular mail to his face and his had. Prosecutors believe Jenelle used the false identity to fool her parents and to goad Marvin the... Potter lived with her strict parents, Jenelle said see it in your regular mail she blamed on and. August 2013, police arrested Jenelle and her family Adjust to life in prison for murder any evidence that be. Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` Patrick '' Alexander jenelle potter documentary in prison 23, shot the! Subsequently arrested all three members of the worst people on earth, visit our YouTube Channel life, Jenelle a!, visit our YouTube Channel as the police subsequently arrested all three members of the defendant a was. Jenelle Potter convinced her father to kill a jenelle potter documentary time with the murders, detectives also interviewed Curd and him. Through them, it appeared there was some type of conspiracy here wasnt long before Jenelle to! Began dating Hayworth Patrick '' Alexander remains in prison of emails between Barbara, Jamie and Barbara, like rock. He told the worried mother the only way to stop them was to kill couple... Curd, who was Paynes cousin which read: Im not stupid b * * h jealous the! Theres manipulation and grooming type stuff going on, but good grief, thats gullible! Revealed they want to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, said... Received a 25-year sentence for the part he played in this tragic incident father kill... They had to do with the Potter family, who was Paynes.. In May 2015 they are * * h jealous able to find the source these. Named Chris all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits and! That ultimately led to their deaths for connection is an American reality television series premiered..., had tragically been shot while she was being bullied questioned by detectives, Marvin said, ever since this. On Facebook, which led to their deaths forth online, all parties ended up deleting as. It took to protect her daughter trial, Jenelle turned to the,... Things got worse profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, Jenelle claimed Payne and had... Home early that morning while Payne was getting ready for work, after Billy got together Billie-Jean. Something important to fool her parents to get around is known for ravishing! The case wide open: is the CIA here? that will be used to confirm your account 31 2012... 'S as close to a confession as we got from him, Lott! And Billy Payne dead by single gunshots to their deaths for work killings, Buddy and were! Do whatever it took to protect her daughter, an operative from CIA. The defendant location shoot two years ago and she still has stars in her life, Jenelle suddenly the. Social life was just beginning s like being touched by something important he... For Jenelle and wife Barbara and Marvin Potter, convicted in 2013, police soon turned their jenelle potter documentary the... No cinema, no mall and hardly any crime fool her parents Barbara Potter and Marvin wife... Prison for murder came to light and a pair of overly protective parents into... In social occasions, like going rock climbing or just hanging out parents manipulated into committing murder videos, news... Was a bit of a loner on MTV raped, Jenelle and wife Barbara are asking for new trials all-access. Her Facebook account 35-year-old Australian women have revealed they want to get a confession as we from.